“ Cozy - inviting - great food. The seared tuna ahi is wonderful!! I also enjoy the bar area and tables in that area. ”

“ A great lunch/work session at Gary's!!!! Espresso Martini is the best around! I had the Taco Burger, which is a special right now and it is amazing! Sat at the bar and had wonderful service. Was a little chilly today but the weather outdoors was freezing as well!!! ”

“ Great dinner spot with wonderful food. The service is friendly, especially when you belly up at the bar. The restaurant is swanky and feels nice and fancy throughout the decor. ”

“ Visiting in town for a wedding, but also had a birthday to celebrate. This was a great choice! We were able to get same day reservations on a Friday night for 6 people at 5:30. The restaurant was packed! Our servers were friendly, efficient and knowledgeable. Our party ordered a variety of dishes: Lobster roll (good, but a bit plain), medium rare prime rib (yum), jambalaya (hard to believe, but as good as if ordered in New Orleans), medium rare New York strip (a little more on the rare side, but tender and flavorful), beef short rib stroganoff (very good, but too many mushrooms for my taste) and chicken cordon bleu (another winner). The restaurant is a bit on the pricey side, but we enjoyed the food and the casual, supper club ambiance. Our daughter made a great choice for her out of state family birthday dinner! ”

“ Tonight was near perfect, apps, entree k desert was delicious. Service was excellent. The hostess and greeters could be more organized. The bar was full, good prices on the happy hour selections. ”

“ Went for Friday lunch fish fry special $20 for pollock and $6 upcharge for walleye. Services was quick and attentive. Sat at a table near the bar where they had sports playing but was not overly loud so you could still hold a conversation without having to yell. The food was delicious and the portions for the basic fish was large and oh so delicious. This is not an all you can eat but the amount they give is plenty so that was not needed. My friend that had the walleye had one large piece instead of multiples and said they would order the regular as they really liked the breading on mine but did certainly enjoy theirs too. ”

“ I recently took some clients to lunch at Gary's Supper Club, and I must say it was a fantastic experience. The place is beautifully maintained and very clean, creating a welcoming atmosphere from the moment you walk in. It wasn't very busy at the time, which made for a nice, relaxed dining experience. We were warmly greeted at the door and promptly taken to our table, where our server came over right away to take our drink orders. I decided on the Prime Rib French Dip with chips, and I was not disappointed. After a short wait of about 10 minutes, our food arrived looking absolutely delicious. My sandwich was juicy, tender, and packed with flavor--one of the best French dips I've had in a long time. The only thing I would have changed is my side choice; my clients ordered the French fries, and they were wonderful! They were on the thicker side (not quite steak fries but thicker than normal fries), crispy, well-seasoned, and full of flavor. Next time, I'll definitely go with those! Overall, it was a great experience with fresh, tasty food that was well worth the price. The ambiance and attention to detail would also make Gary's Supper Club an excellent spot for a date--it's cozy, welcoming, and perfect for a more intimate dining experience. I'm looking forward to returning and highly recommend it to anyone seeking a quality meal in a beautiful setting. ”

“ Gary's Supper Club is a wonderful restaurant right off I-35. Tuesdays lobster is $35:) We try to go at happy hour 2-5pm for half off appetizers too. The server was kind, well informed of all the questions we asked and as professional as they come. I love the new look inside, it very much lives up to the supper club vibe. ”

“ My husband and I had a fantastic date night at Gary's Supper Club recently, and it couldn't have been better! The staff was absolutely wonderful - friendly, attentive, and happy to answer all our questions about the menu. For my meal, I decided to go all out and try the lobster special. It came perfectly grilled (just the way I like it!) and was served with sweet corn, french fries, and brussel sprouts (my side choices). The lobster itself was the star of the show. It was incredibly juicy and flavorful, and honestly, didn't even need butter - the simple lemon drizzle was perfect. Breaking it apart and enjoying the delicious meat was a fun experience in itself! But the deliciousness didn't stop there! Before our meal even arrived, we were treated to a complimentary pre-dinner "freebie." It was a fun little finger-food platter with olives, gummy bears, pickles, and peanuts - a unique and unexpected treat that we really enjoyed. Overall, Gary's Supper Club provided the perfect ambiance for a romantic date night. The food was outstanding, the service was top-notch, and the little touches like the pre-dinner snacks made the experience even more special. We will definitely be back soon! Highly recommend this place for a delicious meal and a great night out. ”

“ This was my first time coming after the renovations and turning into Gary's! Not your traditional supper club vices, definitely more upscale. You do still get a fun little relish tray with pickles, gummy bears and some nuts. Our group ordered some cheese curds to start because they were on special, very good. Crunchy and cheesy! For my main meal I got chicken parmesan. You can tell the sauce was very fresh. It was good, but I'll try something else next time. The rest of the orders were prime rib, lobster roll and jambalaya. The lobster roll was pretty small and not much meat, flavor was there though. The star of the show was the jambalaya. Incredible. Very spicy but filled with meats. We are excited to go back and try some other things. ”